20 S Fourth St Columbia, PA 17512 | phil.JHLutz@comcast.net
Find Us On:
Jay H. Lutz & Co., Inc.
Call Us Today!


Auto, Home, Health, Business, Renters, Life, Boat, Motorcycle, RV, Specialty

Independent Insurance Agency in Columbia, PA

As a local independent insurance agent, we work for YOU! To get the best PRICE and Policy for YOU!
Focusing on Susquehanna Valley of South-Central Penna. and beyond.
Columbia, Wrightsville, Marietta, Mount Joy, Lancaster, York
The independent insurance agency of Jay H. Lutz & Co., Inc. has spent the last 50 years focusing on the insurance needs of their clients in western Lancaster County and eastern York County in Pennsylvania. Bordering the beautiful Susquehanna River, many residents of the towns of Columbia, Wrightsville, Marietta and beyond rely on the employees of Jay H Lutz & Co. as their insurance professionals. Located in a building built in the 1800s, the insurance agency is conveniently located at 20 South 4th Street in historic downtown Columbia.
When you choose a local independent insurance agent such as Jay H. Lutz & Co., we work for YOU to find the best policy for you. Donegal Insurance Group, Progressive, Travelers, Safeco Insurance, Allied, American Modern— are just a few of the insurance carriers that we utilize to compare coverage and prices to fit your requirements.
Lutz Sign — Auto Insurance in Columbia, PA
These are just a few of the insurance companies!
Donegal Logo
Progressive Logo
Travelers Logo
American Modern Logo
Philadelphia Insurance Companies logo
Nationwide Logo
Think Local Logo
Independent Insurance Agent Logo
We live here too! When you call or stop into Jay H Lutz & Co. insurance agency, you will talk to the same person every time so that any questions or concerns are quickly resolved. Coverage questions, claims assistance, billing inquiries, add or remove vehicles—all can be taken care of with a local phone call or visit to our office in downtown Columbia, Pennsylvania.
Office at 20 S 4th Street, Columbia, Pa